I really enjoyed Song of Solomon because of the way the book was written. I felt like reading this novel was like putting a puzzle together on hard mode. Every time I felt like I had an idea of what I was looking at, the next chapter will either shuffle around some of my old pieces or add some that look like they should be part of another puzzle. For example, when Macon is explaining that his harsh behavior towards Ruth are because of what he saw between her and Dr. Foster, I thought I knew what was going on and my puzzle was starting to take shape. Then a few chapters later the book comes back and scrambles up the puzzle again when we find out about Ruth's part of the story. I hate puzzles but I like how the book kept changing from chapter to chapter, it kept the novel interesting because there was always a possibility that a crucial bit of information was being kept away to be revealed later.
As for the characters, I think they all really fall under two categories: Crazy or Will be crazy in a chapter or two. Now to be fair, my definition of crazy is when a character does something that just makes me think "What the heck is he/she doing?'. The only exception that I found was Guitar because earlier on in the book he looked like the normal person we were supposed to understand in the novel. He wasn't related to Milkman's crazy family and was more involved in political activism than upper-middle class parties. But of course I'm always wrong and should have expected a man named Guitar to be part of a secret society called The Seven Days and just like Hagar, becomes determined to kill Milkman by any means necessary. All jokes aside however, the relationships between the characters in this novel are really unique, with Milkman as the focal point of everyone's emotions. He seems to be responsible for the happiness of characters in one chapter while also being the cause of a lot of grief in the next. Whereas in other novels we've read so far, such as The Sun also rises everyone was too drunk to know what was going on so we don't really have a reliable narrator.
I haven't actually finished the book at the time I'm posting it but from what I've read so far, the book is really enjoyable. The novel had a feeling of absurdity in the beginning when they were explaining Not Doctor Street but as the book progressed it seemed to become serious when Hagar is out to kill Milkman. Then all bets are off when the main character runs off to Virginia and gets into bar fights over dong shapes. The book was unpredictable, kept messing up my puzzle, and I liked every chapter of it.
I liked your metaphor of the book being like a puzzle. After finishing it I had a sense of satisfaction, like I would after completing a large puzzle, and also appreciation, or wonder, (can't think of the best word to describe it) at how well written and connected the novel was. The theme of flight came together really well with Milkman learning about the legend of his ancestor flying away, and ultimately connected with Robert Smith's leap in the beginning. Even if I wasn't initially able to understand some of the events in the novel, I enjoyed this book a lot too.
ReplyDeleteThis novel takes a pretty ambiguous view on "crazy"--it's not entirely a bad thing, although it does lead Guitar and Hagar down increasingly dark and destructive (murderous and self-destructive) paths. But in part 1, when Milkman is complacently dismissing everyone else around him as "crazy," it starts to seem like his version of "sanity" isn't all that appealing, either. "Crazy" is associated with love, passion, caring intensely about something or someone (just as Macon always dismisses Pilate as "crazy," but we see in her a love for life and a passion for the people she cares about, whereas Macon is cold and distant from everyone in his life). Milkman seems not quite crazy enough, at some points in the novel.
ReplyDeleteAs you point out, everyone in this book is somewhat "crazy". Maybe this is the new norm, and all of these things seem normal to all the crazy people in this book. For instance, Milkman's somewhat incestuous relationship with Hagar is not a huge issue to his community. I think that Morrison created this crazy community that doesn't quite realize it to show that no one is exempt from having issues, no matter what it may look like.
ReplyDeleteI agree on the way the whole book fits together, but I love that its clear that Morrison has a clear image of the puzzle in her head every step of the way. I guess the only non-crazy character really by the end is Milkman? And I don't know, Macon seems justified in all of his actions, he never struck me as crazy, just misguided and cruel, which is worse than being the kind of crazy that Pilate is for sure.
ReplyDeleteI also love the unpredictability of Morrison's writing. She led me on this journey with Milkman, and not once did I just expect a certain turnout and was right. She also gives everyone an equal chance for judgement I think. No character is perfect, every character has some sort of "crazy" and good. For example, Hagar tries to kill Milkman at the end of every month. However, we also have a full chapter dedicated to her in Part II, which gives us more of a glimpse on her side of the story, indeed a tragic one. I was definitely more sympathetic towards her after reading that. I feel that Morrison encourages us to realize the many different facets she creates for her characters, making them more complex and enjoyable to get to know.
ReplyDelete